Giving and Receiving Feedback

The Gift of Feedback

Feedback is one of the greatest gifts you can give or receive. It's information that helps us grow, improve, and see ourselves more clearly. Yet many people avoid giving or can't receive feedback well. This reluctance stems from fear: fear of conflict, fear of hurting feelings, fear of being vulnerable, or fear of damaging relationships. When we withhold feedback, we deny others the opportunity to improve and we allow small issues to fester into larger problems.

The truth is that feedback, when delivered with care and received with openness, strengthens relationships rather than damaging them. It demonstrates that you value the relationship enough to invest in someone's growth. Research consistently shows that high-performing teams and individuals actively seek and provide feedback, creating a continuous improvement cycle that elevates everyone involved.

Consider the alternative: without feedback, people operate with blind spots, repeating behaviors that undermine their effectiveness without ever understanding why. They miss opportunities for growth and develop defensive patterns that make future feedback even harder to receive. Organizations without healthy feedback cultures stagnate, making the same mistakes repeatedly while talent languishes underdeveloped.

Effective feedback creates clarity. It transforms vague dissatisfaction into specific, actionable information. It replaces assumptions with understanding. When someone knows exactly what they're doing well and what needs adjustment, they gain agency over their own development. This clarity builds confidence and competence simultaneously.

The SBI Model for Giving Feedback

The SBI (Situation-Behavior-Impact) model provides a clear framework for delivering specific, non-judgmental feedback. Developed by the Center for Creative Leadership, this approach removes subjectivity and focuses on observable facts and measurable consequences. By separating what happened from your interpretation of it, you reduce defensiveness and increase the likelihood that feedback will be heard and acted upon.

Many feedback attempts fail because they conflate observation with judgment. Saying "you were rude" is an interpretation that invites argument. Saying "you interrupted Sarah three times" is an observable fact that's harder to dispute. The SBI model helps you stay grounded in specifics rather than drowning in generalizations that feel like character attacks.

The power of SBI lies in its clarity and completeness. Each component serves a specific purpose: Situation provides context, Behavior describes observable actions, and Impact explains consequences. Together, they create a complete picture that helps the recipient understand not just what they did, but why it matters and how they might adjust going forward.

Timing & Privacy

The timing and setting of feedback dramatically affect how it's received. Excellent feedback delivered at the wrong time or in the wrong place can backfire spectacularly, creating resentment instead of growth. Understanding when and where to provide feedback is as important as the content itself.

Public praise and private criticism isn't just a nice principle—it's rooted in how humans process social information. Positive feedback in front of peers reinforces desired behavior while building the recipient's reputation and status. Constructive feedback in private protects dignity and reduces defensive reactions. Violating this principle—praising privately when public recognition would be meaningful, or criticizing publicly when privacy would protect the relationship—undermines trust and respect.

Timing matters because emotional state affects receptivity. Delivering critical feedback when someone is already stressed, angry, or defensive guarantees it won't land productively. The ideal time is when both parties are calm, focused, and have adequate time for discussion. Rushing feedback or catching someone at a bad moment wastes the opportunity and potentially damages the relationship.

Proximity to the behavior also matters, but not always in obvious ways. While feedback should generally come soon after the event while details are fresh, sometimes immediate feedback overwhelms. If emotions are running high or the person needs time to process what happened, waiting a few hours or until the next day can be wiser than striking while the iron is hot.

Balancing Positive & Constructive

The ratio of positive to constructive feedback matters more than most people realize. Research by John Gottman shows that relationships thrive with approximately 5:1 ratio of positive to negative interactions. In workplace contexts, high-performing teams tend to maintain a ratio around 5.6:1 positive to negative feedback. This doesn't mean avoiding necessary criticism—it means building a foundation of recognition and appreciation that makes constructive feedback more credible and easier to receive.

Many managers fall into the "no news is good news" trap, only providing feedback when something goes wrong. This creates an environment where feedback itself becomes feared and avoided. When people only hear from you when there's a problem, they start ducking your calls and avoiding conversations. Regular positive feedback normalizes the feedback process, making it a natural part of working together rather than a dreaded event.

The compliment sandwich—starting with praise, delivering criticism, ending with praise—has fallen out of favor for good reason. People see through it. After experiencing this pattern a few times, they learn to brace for the "but" that signals the real message. The initial praise loses credibility, feeling like mere preamble to the criticism. The ending praise feels hollow, like you're trying to soften the blow rather than offering genuine recognition.

Better approach: Give positive and constructive feedback separately, in their own right. When someone does something well, tell them specifically what and why. When adjustment is needed, address it directly without burying it in unrelated praise. Each type of feedback carries more weight when it stands alone, delivered with sincerity rather than as part of a manipulative sandwich formula.

Receiving Feedback Without Defense

How you receive feedback may be more important than how you give it. The person who can hear hard truths without defensiveness possesses a superpower that accelerates their growth exponentially. Yet our natural instinct when criticized is to defend, explain, justify, or deflect. This instinct protects our ego in the moment while sabotaging our development in the long run.

Receiving feedback well requires recognizing that your immediate emotional reaction—the spike of defensiveness, the urge to explain or counter-argue—is normal but not useful. That reaction is your ego protecting itself from perceived threat. The key is to notice the reaction without acting on it. Breathe. Create space between the feedback and your response. In that space lies the opportunity for growth.

Most feedback contains at least a grain of truth, even if it's poorly delivered or mixed with inaccuracies. Your job as the recipient isn't to evaluate whether the feedback is "right" or "fair" in the moment of receiving it. That judgment comes later, after you've fully understood what's being said and had time to reflect. During the feedback conversation itself, your only job is to listen, understand, and appreciate the courage it took to share.

The people who rise fastest and farthest are those who actively seek feedback rather than waiting to receive it. They ask "What's one thing I could do better?" after presentations. They request specific input on their development areas. They thank people for difficult feedback and demonstrate they've acted on it. This creates a virtuous cycle: the more you welcome feedback, the more honest feedback you receive, which accelerates your growth, which encourages more people to invest in your development.

Common Feedback Scenarios

Practicing feedback with real scenarios builds your confidence and competence. The following examples demonstrate how to apply SBI and other feedback principles across common workplace and personal situations. Notice how each scenario focuses on specific, observable behaviors and clear impacts rather than vague character judgments.

When preparing to give feedback, write out your SBI statement beforehand. This preparation prevents you from rambling, getting emotional, or forgetting key points. It also helps you check whether you're focused on behavior (changeable) versus personality (fixed), and whether your impact statement is specific or vague.

Remember that these are starting points for conversations, not monologues. After delivering your SBI feedback, pause and give the other person space to respond. The goal is dialogue and mutual understanding, not one-way pronouncement. Listen to their perspective, clarify misunderstandings, and work together toward solutions.

Knowledge Check

Test your understanding of this chapter's key concepts.